The season finale of The Bachelorette has ignited a firestorm of criticism, with fans accusing the producers of exploiting Jenn Tran’s heartbreak for the sake of ratings. The controversy centers on the show’s decision to air Tran’s proposal to Devin Strader, despite their engagement having ended weeks earlier.
This is not the first time Season 21 of The Bachelorette has faced criticism. The season has seen a steady decline in ratings, with viewership dropping significantly since its premiere. Fans have expressed their dissatisfaction with various aspects of the show, from the lack of drama to the perceived lack of interest from the lead herself. Some have even accused the show of being scripted, citing Jenn’s ex-boyfriend Matt’s surprise appearance as a desperate attempt by producers to boost ratings.
Read more: ‘The Bachelorette’: First Asian-American Contestant, Thomas Nguyen, Dives into Love and Reality TV
During the live finale, Tran tearfully revealed that Strader had broken off the engagement over a phone call, confessing that he never loved her. “He had basically said that he didn’t love me anymore and didn’t feel the same way and felt like something had been off since the second he proposed, and regretted getting engaged,” she shared.
The situation took an even more distressing turn when the producers decided to air Tran’s proposal, forcing her to relive the painful moment in front of a live audience and her ex-fiancé.
Fans were quick to condemn the show’s handling of the situation. “This may be the cruelest thing this show has ever done,” one viewer wrote on X (formerly Twitter). “I can’t believe they’re making her watch herself propose to this man after all this.”
The backlash also highlighted concerns about the casting process. One fan commented: “Producers set up the first Asian lead and humiliated her. I’m heartbroken for Jenn because WHY on earth didn’t they cast men FOR her. This is crazy.”
Read more: John Cho’s Son Discovers ‘Harold & Kumar’ Legacy as Sequel Talks Emerge
The backlash extends beyond the finale itself, with many questioning the show’s exploitative nature. Critics argue that “The Bachelor franchise has been struggling with middling ratings,” and that Jenn’s emotional devastation provided the grand finale they needed. “There’s no denying the show manufactured a memorable climax — we can only hope they did not permanently damage a real person’s psyche in the process,” one commentator observed.
The Bachelorette‘s season finale exposed the show’s callous disregard for its participants, exploiting Tran’s heartbreak for dramatic effect and ratings. Tran’s genuine tears became the centerpiece of a cruel spectacle, serving as a stark reminder that reality TV’s glossy facade masks a disturbing reality where real people are emotionally manipulated and traumatized.
Read more: Greta Lee and Andrew Scott to Star in Sci-Fi Romance ‘My Notes on Mars’
This incident has reignited discussions about the treatment of reality TV participants, echoing Catherine Horowitz’s 2022 observation: “For those who participate in it, reality television isn’t manufactured at all; it’s a real part of their lives, something that permanently impacts them.”
As viewers, we are left to question: at what cost are we willing to be entertained?
